Scars are a natural part of the body’s healing process after an injury, surgery, or skin trauma. However, for many people, visible scars can be a source of discomfort and insecurity. Silicone-based scar gels are widely considered the most effective, non-invasive option for reducing the appearance of scars. Among the top products in this category are Scarless Silicone Gel and Newgelplus, both of which have built solid reputations for their ability to flatten, soften, and improve the texture of scars. While both products are based on proven silicone technology, they differ in formulation, ingredients, and specific benefits. This article compares these two products comprehensively to help you decide which suits your scar treatment needs better.
Overview of Scarless Silicone Gel
Scarless Silicone Gel is a high-quality scar treatment that combines medical-grade silicone with nourishing ingredients, delivering a comprehensive solution for scar management. This gel is formulated to improve the texture of scars and enhance their overall appearance. Scarless provides additional benefits beyond typical silicone gels by incorporating squalane and vitamin C.
The medical-grade silicone forms a breathable and flexible layer over the scar, which helps to flatten and soften the tissue while retaining moisture, promoting a more effective healing process.
Squalane: This moisturizing ingredient keeps the skin hydrated, improves elasticity, and prevents the dryness or tightness often associated with scars.
Vitamin C: With its antioxidant and brightening properties, vitamin C helps reduce scar pigmentation, improving skin tone and making scars less visible.
Scarless Silicone Gel is free from fragrances and suitable for all skin types, including sensitive and acne-prone skin. Its lightweight and non-greasy formula makes it comfortable for daily use and ensures the skin remains soft, hydrated, and protected throughout the healing process.
Overview of Newgel+
Newgelplus is another well-known name in the scar treatment market. It focuses on providing effective silicone-based scar management. It incorporates polymerized siloxanes (a form of silicone) and tocopherol (vitamin E) to offer a solution for reducing the appearance and discomfort of scars.
- Polymerized siloxanes: This key ingredient forms a protective silicone layer over the scar, which helps to flatten and soften the tissue over time.
- Vitamin E (Tocopherol): Vitamin E is an antioxidant known for its ability to improve skin texture and help repair damaged skin. This can make scars less noticeable and improve skin elasticity.
Newgelplus is designed to be worn comfortably under clothing. It dries quickly and leaves no greasy residue, making it convenient for people who need a product that is easy to use in their daily routine without causing discomfort.
Formulation and Ingredients
Scarless Silicone Gel
Scarless takes a multi-faceted approach to scar healing by combining medical-grade silicone with ingredients that support skin hydration and overall appearance. Its inclusion of squalane sets it apart from many other scar treatments, as it provides intense moisture, which is essential for preventing scar tissue from becoming dry and tight. This moisture helps keep the skin around the scar elastic, making it less likely to crack or itch during healing.
Additionally, the presence of vitamin C in Scarless adds an essential dimension to its formula. Vitamin C is known for its skin-brightening properties, helping to reduce discoloration around scars and making them less visible. It also provides antioxidant protection, reducing inflammation and promoting overall skin health.
The formulation is designed to be non-comedogenic, meaning it won’t clog pores, which is especially important for people using the product on facial scars or areas prone to acne.
Newgelplus
Newgelplus takes a more focused approach. Its key ingredients are polymerized siloxanes and vitamin E. The primary function of the silicone in Newgelplus is to form a thin, protective barrier over the scar that retains moisture and flattens the tissue. Over time, this helps soften the scar and make it less noticeable.
Vitamin E is included for its skin-repairing properties. This ingredient is known to help with skin healing and improve texture and elasticity, making it especially beneficial for hard or thick scars. Vitamin E also adds some moisturizing benefits, but it doesn’t provide the same hydration level as squalane in Scarless.
Newgelplus is fragrance-free and hypoallergenic, suitable for most skin types, including sensitive skin.
Application and Texture
Scarless Silicone Gel
Scarless Silicone Gel is easy to apply thanks to its lightweight and smooth texture. The gel glides on effortlessly and dries without any sticky or greasy residue. While it takes a few minutes to absorb, once dry fully, it forms an invisible layer over the scar, allowing it to breathe while being protected.
The added hydration from squalane ensures that the skin around the scar stays soft and supple throughout the day, which is particularly beneficial for scars in areas that tend to dry out quickly. Scarless can be used twice a day—morning and night—for optimal results, and its gentle formula makes it a good option for daily use over extended periods.
Newgelplus
Newgelplus also offers a smooth and lightweight texture that makes applying easy. It dries quickly, a significant advantage for those pressed for time or want to wear it under clothing without worrying about residue or stickiness. Once applied, it leaves a thin, invisible layer over the scar, helping it heal without being overly noticeable.
The inclusion of vitamin E helps provide some moisturizing effects, but Newgelplus is more focused on scar flattening rather than hydration. The gel is well-suited for use under clothing, making it convenient for arms, legs, or chest scars.
Efficacy and Results
Scarless Silicone Gel
Scarless Silicone Gel offers a comprehensive approach to scar healing, addressing not only the texture of the scar but also its appearance. The moisturizing benefits of squalane help to keep the skin around the scar hydrated, reducing discomfort and dryness. Vitamin C helps brighten the scarred area and reduce pigmentation, making scars less visible.
With consistent use, many users report that scars become softer, flatter, and less red, while the surrounding skin looks healthier and more even in tone. Scarless works particularly well for scars that need both texture improvement and discoloration correction, making it a great option for those looking to address multiple aspects of scar healing.
Newgelplus
Newgelplus is highly regarded for its ability to flatten and soften scars, mainly raised or thick ones. The silicone barrier helps retain moisture and improve the overall texture of the scar, while vitamin E repairs damaged skin and improves elasticity. Over time, scars become less noticeable, and the skin feels softer.
While it may not provide the same hydration level as Scarless, Newgelplus effectively reduces scar thickness and improves the overall appearance of scars, especially for users looking for a straightforward, silicone-based solution.
Suitability for Different Types of Scars
Scarless Silicone Gel
Scarless suits many scars, including those from surgery, injury, burns, and acne. Its hydrating and brightening properties make it particularly effective for older scars that may need more attention to texture and pigmentation. The formula’s added focus on moisture also makes it ideal for scars that tend to dry out or become tight, such as those on the hands or face.
Newgelplus
Newgelplus is best suited for thick, raised, or hard scars, such as keloids or hypertrophic scars. The silicone in Newgelplus is particularly effective at flattening and softening these scars over time. It is also a good option for scars in high-friction areas, as the gel dries quickly and remains intact under clothing.
Conclusion
Scarless Silicone Gel and Newgelplus offer highly effective solutions for scar treatment but cater to slightly different needs. Scarless excels with its multi-faceted approach, offering benefits beyond scar texture, such as hydration and skin-brightening effects, thanks to squalane and vitamin C. This makes it an excellent option for individuals looking for a more comprehensive solution to their scars’ appearance and texture.
On the other hand, Newgelplus focuses more on scar texture, providing a straightforward silicone-based formula that effectively flattens and softens scars, mainly raised or thick ones. Its inclusion of vitamin E helps improve skin elasticity, though it may not provide the same hydration level as Scarless.
Ultimately, choosing these two products depends on your specific scar treatment needs. If you’re looking for a solution that addresses both hydration and discoloration, Scarless may be the better option. If your priority is flattening and softening thicker scars, Newgelplus is an excellent choice. Both are highly effective, making either a valuable addition to your scar care routine.
